Norfolk council moves to scrap ‘net zero’ from policies

5
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Reform has put the phrase “net zero” on the chopping block at County Hall with a move to ban the term, even though the policies behind it remain largely intact.

The party’s administration wants the term removed from Norfolk County Council policies, replacing it instead with a pledge to make "best endeavours to decarbonise in the interest of an improved environment, where this is cost effective".

However, the authority's actual policies to achieve net zero by 2030 and to work with others to hit the government's 2050 net zero target have yet to be changed.

Senior Reform councillors say they will accept money from central government for schemes such as electric buses and new cycle lanes, but projects using its own money will be subject to strict value for money checks.

It follows a report by officers into the measures the council has been taking to move towards net zero, which Reform councillors requested after taking control of County Hall from the Conservatives in May's elections.

But critics have accused Reform of "political theatre", with the council's former Conservative leader Kay Mason Billig saying the administration had wasted officer time trying to find money being squandered on non-existent "crazy green schemes".

What does net zero mean?

Net zero means achieving a balance between carbon emitted into the atmosphere, and the carbon which is removed from it.

This is done by moving away from use of fossil fuels.

In 2019, the UK government set a target requiring the UK to bring all greenhouse gas emissions to net zero by 2050.

County Hall had a target to make its estate, including its buildings, net zero by 2030.

What did the report find?

County Hall officials said it had not been possible to produce a fully definitive listing of the financial implications of all climate-related activities.

They said that was partly because the costs of some of the work done, which would reduce carbon emission, would be done in any case for value for money reasons.

Norfolk County Council has switched off some streets lights for part of the night (Image: Antony Kelly)

Projects officers highlighted as reducing carbon emissions included replacing street lights with LED bulbs and switching them off for part of the night, along with the authority's £83m Future Ready initiative.

That scheme, agreed under the previous Conservative administration, aims to make properties owned by the council more energy efficient.

That includes making changes, such as installing heat pumps, to some 200 council buildings - including fire stations, libraries and museums.

What do councillors say?

Nick Taylor, Reform's cabinet member for commercial assets and revenue generation, who triggered the probe into the council's net zero spending with a council motion earlier this year, welcomed the report.

Nick Taylor (Image: Nick Taylor)

He said: "There are certain things that won't be happening any more. The council for some time has had a a program called the Future Ready program which addresses the entire estate and and that program has many, many merits.

"But one thing it has brought about in recent years is the ad hoc replacement of gas or oil boilers with air source heating systems in certain dwellings on the county farms estate.

"Those are buildings that were totally unsuitable for such heating systems, where the tenants have been left with much more costly fuel bills and properties that are are never warm enough.

"I'm pleased to say that sort of thing won't be happening anymore."

Kabeer Kher (Image: Norfolk County Council)

Kabeer Kher, cabinet member for business, skills and agriculture, said: "I'm really pleased to see this report confirms that by and large, this council does not subscribe to net zero ideology, but instead takes decisions on a proper cost benefit analysis.

"Where there is net zero spending on projects like electric buses or cycle lanes, it is funded by central government using fully funded schemes like active travel rather than from local council taxpayers. That is a decision of the Labour government, not ours."

At a meeting of Reform's cabinet, members agreed that, as part of an ongoing review of the council's constitution, that references to net zero be removed from council documents.

The words would be replaced with wording that the council makes "best endeavours to decarbonise in the interest of an improved environment, where this is cost effective."

What do political opponents say?

Kay Mason Billig, leader of the Conservative group and former leader of County Hall before Reform's local election victory in May, said Reform's 'net zero witch hunt' had been a waste of time.

Kay Mason Billig (Image: Henry Durand)

She said: "Reform came into office claiming they would uncover millions of pounds being squandered on crazy green schemes.

"Six months later, their own officers have produced a report which comprehensively undermines that claim.

"They found no net zero spending spree, no hidden pot of savings and no evidence to justify their rhetoric. The only wasteful exercise this review has clearly exposed is their own.

"Norfolk faces enormous financial pressures. Residents deserve serious leadership and credible savings proposals, not political theatre."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos