Couple’s bid to save their home from demolition fails

PUBLISHED: 13:57 11 October 2017 | UPDATED: 08:59 12 October 2017

The High Court in London. Picture: Steve Parsons/PA Wire

The High Court in London. Picture: Steve Parsons/PA Wire

A couple’s long-running battle to save their home from being demolished has ended in failure at London’s High Court.

David and Ann Usher pleaded with Deputy Judge Natalie Lieven QC with to over-ride Forest Heath District Council’s demolition order and allow their home at Small Fen Farm, Brandon to remain standing.

Instead, she dismissed their challenge and ruled that the council had “not erred” in taking its decision.

In a complex judgment running to over 7,000 words, she said the history of the case was a lengthy one dating back to 2012, when the council issued an enforcement notice ordering demolition of the property and removal of all material from the site on the basis that it had been built without planning consent.

However in September 2014, with the house still in place, the Ushers submitted an application for temporary planning consent for five years.

They applied on the basis that changes of planning policy might take place in the area and also that the medical condition of Mr Usher’s mother, who was in poor health, should be taken into consideration.

That application was refused but the battle dragged on until in January this year, when the council issued an ultimatum that they intended to move in and demolish the property on January 30.

Three days before the deadline though, a High Court judge put everything on legal hold by granting the Ushers consent to take their challenge to the High Court.

Lawyers for the Ushers argued, among other things, that the council had committed a legal errors in the way they had handled the matter.

They also claimed that the demolition plan was “disproportionate and unreasonable” and that the move to carry it out was “unlawful and unfair”. It was also argued that there was failure on the part of the council to consider alternative moves.

However, Deputy Judge Lieven rejected all the arguments.

She said she did not consider the stance of the council was procedurally unfair. Nor did she think the council’s refusal to extend a dead-line was “irrational or disproportionate.”

And she said she considered the council decision on the action they intended had been “entirely clear and properly communicated”.

“I do not think the Council erred in law in not taking any other steps before proceeding with direct action,” she said.

Other news

Yesterday, 09:19

The number of civil partnerships in Norfolk has fallen dramatically since same-sex marriage was legalised.

Friday, August 17, 2018

A Swaffham grain trader has bought a Yorkshire competitor in an undisclosed-value deal.

Friday, August 17, 2018

Swaffham town councillors have agreed to apply for a £6 million government loan to fund the development of 51 new homes.

Friday, August 17, 2018

A First World War memorial campaign led by former head of the army Lord Dannatt will see 6ft tall Tommy silhouette statues erected around the county.

Most Read

Friday, July 6, 2018

An emotional farewell has been given to former Norfolk County Council leader Cliff Jordan.

Read more
Alison Thomas
Tuesday, September 26, 2017

The closure of a major American airbase is to be delayed by another year.

Read more
Monday, February 6, 2017

The distinctive sight and sound of the US Air Force’s (USAF) tankers roaring above East Anglia has been a regular feature for 25 years.

Read more
United Kingdom
Monday, March 28, 2016

An academy trust that runs four Norfolk high schools has announced plans to cut 10 teaching posts because of rising costs and falling income.

Read more
Attleborough Academy
Sunday, June 21, 2015

Love-struck Tim Round proposed to Rhiannon Shepherd after a flash mob dance by her brothers and sisters.

Read more

Local Weather



max temp: 20°C

min temp: 17°C

Digital Edition

Read the Watton and Swaffham Times e-edition today

Show Job Lists

Newsletter Sign Up

Watton and Swaffham Times weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy